Condition Grading Guide
Transparent condition assessment for every vintage piece in our archive.
Our Grading Philosophy
We believe in complete transparency when describing vintage condition. Every piece is thoroughly inspected and photographed, with all flaws clearly documented. Our grading system helps you understand exactly what to expect.
Remember: Vintage items have lived a life. Minor imperfections are part of their character and authenticity. We celebrate the history in every piece.
Condition Grades
Deadstock / NWT
New with tags, never worn
- • Original tags attached
- • No signs of wear whatsoever
- • May show minor storage aging
- • Factory folds may be present
- • Extremely rare for true vintage
Near Mint
Exceptional condition with minimal wear
- • Worn 1-2 times maximum
- • No visible flaws to casual observation
- • Possible light fading from storage
- • No stains, holes, or damage
- • Graphics remain vibrant
Excellent
Light wear with no major flaws
- • Light general wear throughout
- • Minor fading consistent with age
- • No significant stains or holes
- • Graphics show minimal cracking
- • Great for wearing or collecting
Very Good
Moderate wear with minor flaws
- • Visible but not distracting wear
- • Some fading or discoloration
- • Minor stains or small repairs
- • Graphics show some cracking/wear
- • Still very wearable
Good
Noticeable wear with repairable flaws
- • Obvious signs of regular wear
- • Fading throughout
- • Repairable holes or stains
- • Graphics significantly cracked
- • Character piece for true vintage lovers
Fair
Heavy wear, for collectors only
- • Extensive wear and fading
- • Multiple flaws or damage
- • May have holes or heavy staining
- • Graphics heavily worn
- • Best for study or pattern reference
Understanding Common Vintage Flaws
Fading
Natural color loss from washing and sun exposure. Can be overall or localized (shoulder fading, etc.).
Impact: Usually minimal unless severe
Pilling
Small fabric balls formed from friction. Common on cotton blends and in high-friction areas.
Impact: Cosmetic only, easily removed
Cracking
Graphics showing lines or missing pieces. Natural aging of screen print ink, especially on stretch areas.
Impact: Adds character, part of vintage appeal
Pinholes
Tiny holes from wear or moths. Often found in thin, single-stitch tees. We note size and location.
Impact: Depends on size and location
Staining
Discoloration from spills, sweat, or storage. We describe type, size, and location of all stains.
Impact: Varies by visibility
Yellowing
Age-related discoloration, especially on white items. Often from storage conditions or natural aging.
Impact: Common in vintage, adds patina
Our Photography Standards
Every listing includes detailed photos showing:
- • Front and back full views
- • Close-ups of all graphics and prints
- • Tag details and copyright information
- • Any flaws or areas of wear
- • Accurate color representation
- • Measurements being taken
We photograph in natural light when possible and never use filters. What you see is what you get.
How Condition Affects Value
Condition is a major factor in vintage pricing, but rarity and desirability also play crucial roles. Here's a general guide:
* Extremely rare pieces may command high prices regardless of condition
Questions About Condition?
Need more details about a specific item? We're happy to provide additional photos or information.
Contact Us